POLITICISING COMMODIFICATION

European Governance and Labour Politics from the Financial Crisis to the Covid Emergency

Roland Erne, Sabina Stan, Darragh Golden, Imre Szabó, Vincenzo Maccarrone

 

Cambridge University Press, 2024  •  PB: £ 29.99 / $ 39.99  •  ISBN: 978-1-0090-5436-2

Order print copy with 20% discount code (POCO24) here   •   Download free open access e-book here


Book Description

This book examines the new economic governance (NEG) regime that the EU adopted after 2008. Its novel research design captures the supranational formulation of NEG prescriptions and their uneven deployment across countries (Germany, Italy, Ireland, Romania), policy areas (employment relations, public services), and sectors (transport, water, healthcare). NEG led to a much more vertical mode of EU integration, and its commodification agenda unleashed a plethora of union and social-movement protests, including transnationally. The book presents findings that are crucial for the prospects of European democracy, as labour politics is essential in framing the struggles about the direction of NEG along a commodification–decommodification axis rather than a national–EU axis. To shed light on corresponding processes at EU level, it upscales insights on the historical role that labour movements have played in the development of democracy and welfare states.


Book Reviews

Newspapers & Magazines

Dillon, P. (2024) 'NEUU lens | Paul Dillon reviews politicising commodification. European Governance and Labour Politics from the Financial Crisis to the Covid Emergency. Village Magazine, October-November.

Giugăl, A. (2024) 'INTERVIU | Sabina Stan, profesor la Dublin City University: „Transformarea muncii și a serviciilor publice în mărfuri, care pot fi vândute și cumpărate pe piață, alimentează mișcările extremiste”', Libertatea, 10 July. (Libertatea is Romania's biggest newspaper)

Méda, D. (2024) 'Nous avons besoin de plus d’Union européenne', Le Monde, 25 May.

Méda, D. (2024) 'Sociologist Dominique Méda: 'We need more European Union''. Le Monde (English edition), 27 May.

Academic Journals

Politicising Commodification stands to be one of the new classics for anyone interested in how the EU economic governance ticks and is contested across time.’ Cornel Ban (2024) Book Review Forum: Politics and Commodification, ILR Review, 77(6) (forthcoming)

Politicising Commodification makes a major contribution to the understanding of contemporary European economic, social, and political dynamics by brilliantly taking up the challenge of jointly examining the commodification agenda of the new economic governance (NEG) of the EU and the conditions of possibility of transnational protest movements in the post-2008 context.’ Élodie Béthoux (2024) Book Review Forum: Allies against Commodification, ILR Review, 77(6) (forthcoming)

Politicising Commodification adds a great deal to our understanding of EU public policy developments over the past two decades. It will be required reading for all scholars working in this field.’ Martin Rhodes (2024) Book Review Forum: The EU Public Policy Dimnension, ILR Review, 77(6) (forthcoming)

The book brings to the fore a new and engaging way of understanding and rethinking the neoliberal problem and will no doubt be a point of reference in the endeavors to understand the options available to progressive forces in the EU.' Miguel Martínez Lucio (2024) Book Review Forum: The “Mangerialising” of the European Union, ILR Review, 77(6) (forthcoming)


Endorsements of 'Politicising Commodification'

'An enduring legacy of the financial crisis is the EU's embrace of a new economic governance regime, which imitates that of private sector multinational corporations. In this path-breaking, multi-dimensional comparative analysis, Erne and colleagues compellingly draw out the consequences for: the changed character of European integration; the (im)balance between the EU's economic and social dimensions; the EU's underdeveloped democratic polity; and counter interventions by social movements and organised labour.' Paul Marginson, Emeritus Professor of Industrial Relations, University of Warwick

 

'Politicising Commodification provides original and rigorous analysis of the EU's new economic governance regime - from 2008 up to and including the Recovery and Resilience Facility - that calls academics and policymakers to pay heed to the democratic challenges that the EU must face.' Imelda Maher, Sutherland Professor of European Law, University College Dublin

 

'This is a trail-blazing book in several different ways. First, it develops a new approach to policy analysis that researchers in many fields will find helpful and worthy of imitation. Second, it presents original research on European Union policy on an unusual and instructive selection of countries and sectors. Finally, and perhaps most important, it shows how the study of policies must include conflict around and protest against those policies, and their impact in turn on the policymakers.' Colin Crouch, Emeritus Professor, University of Warwick

 

'This work analyses the post-2008 transformation of EU interventions on employment relations and public services from horizontal market integration to more vertical country-specific policy prescriptions, surveillance, and enforcement. It documents the extent to which this change offered concrete targets for contentious transnational counter-movements, but also generated obstacles to transnational collective action, setting countries in competition with one another. The book is a bold and fresh attempt to analyse EU politics with a commodification-decommodification approach rather than the usual national-EU axis.' Stefano Bartolini, Emeritus Professor, European University Institute

 

'This is a book for anyone interested in the dynamics of European integration. Rarely have the causes and consequences of 'functional spill-over' been so clearly captured and explored.' Philippe C. Schmitter, Emeritus Professor, European University Institute

 

'Politicising Commodification offers fascinating new insights on how the new economic governance in the EU is deployed differentially across member states and various policies. While strengthening integration, it also triggers important political responses by civil society. The book is key to understanding how European policymaking works.' Adrienne Héritier, Emeritus Professor, European University Institute

 

'Based on an original theoretical model and rich empirical evidence, this volume contributes much to our knowledge of the threats for democracy as well as the potential for resistance.' Donatella della Porta, Professor of Political Sciences, Scuola Normale Superiore, Firenze

 

'This book makes sense of the relationships between EU economic governance, policy developments, and political conflict in a unique - comparative, cross-sectoral, and longitudinal - fashion across labour markets, as well as transport, water, and healthcare services. It gathers an impressive sum of cutting-edge qualitative research providing the big picture as well as a critical assessment.' Amandine Crespy, Professor of Political Science and EU Studies, Université libre de Bruxelles

 

'Politicising Commodification constitutes a true tour de force.' Martin Seeleib-Kaiser, Professor of Comparative Public Policy, Universität Tübingen

 

'This is rich and ambitious book will be of interest to EU policy scholars across disciplines.' Gráinne de Búrca, Professor of Law, European University Institute

 

'This is an impressively detailed study of the EU's new economic governance regime, which has imposed neoliberal prescriptions to some extent by stealth, as exemplified in four countries and three sectors. The authors offer a nuanced assessment of the possibilities for resistance.' Richard Hyman, Emeritus Professor of Industrial Relations, London School of Economics and Political Science

 

'This major research monograph charts the post-2008 shift from market-driven horizontal European integration to a political mode of vertical integration. As the authors make clear, it is trade unions and social movements that are in a key position to challenge the overarching commodification script. A must read for everyone interested in shifting Europe towards a union of social justice!' Andreas Bieler, Professor of Political Economy, University of Nottingham

 

'This book offers an empirically rich, methodologically innovative, and theoretically sophisticated analysis of the EU's shift to its new economic governance regime after the financial crisis of 2008 and its political and social consequences.' Elke Heins, Senior Lecturer in Social Policy, University of Edinburgh

 

'This book is an essential contribution to the debate on EU governance, its relationship to labour politics, and the future of democratic governance in Europe.' Paul Copeland, Professor of Public Policy, Queen Mary University of London